The three winners of New York's downstate casino licenses — awarded in late 2025 after a four-year competitive process — are now grappling with construction cost overruns, regulatory delays, and softer demand projections than initial bids assumed. iGaming Business reported this month that all three projects are tracking 8-14 months behind original timelines, and at least one is in active renegotiation with state regulators.
The three license winners (MGM at Yonkers, Genting at Aqueduct, and Bally's at the Bronx site) initially projected combined annual gross gaming revenue of $4.8 billion once fully operational. Updated 2026 projections from independent analysts now suggest a combined $3.6-4.0 billion — still substantial, but $800M-$1.2B lower than the original assumptions used to justify the licensing fees.
Where Each Project Stands
MGM Empire City (Yonkers)
MGM's Yonkers expansion is the most advanced of the three. The existing video lottery facility is being upgraded to full-scale commercial casino operation, with table games and a Vegas-style hotel addition under construction. Original opening: Q4 2026. Revised target: Q2 2027 due to permitting delays and revised structural plans.
MGM has not requested additional time formally but has signaled to investors that timeline risk exists. The upside: as a brownfield expansion, MGM faces fewer construction risks than the greenfield projects.
Genting Resorts World NYC (Aqueduct)
Genting's expansion of its existing Resorts World property has hit zoning challenges around its proposed hotel tower. The casino floor expansion is on track for Q1 2027, but the integrated resort components (hotel, convention space) may not complete until late 2028. Genting is reportedly evaluating whether to phase the opening.
Bally's Bronx Project
Bally's faces the most significant challenges. The greenfield project at Ferry Point Park has run into multiple environmental review delays and faces ongoing community opposition. Construction has not begun as of May 2026, and the most realistic opening estimate is now late 2028 — nearly two years behind original timeline.
For players following developments in the broader U.S. casino market, our top online casinos rankings cover the legal options currently available in states with established iGaming markets.
What's Driving the Pessimism
Construction Costs
NYC construction costs have risen 22% since the bids were originally submitted in 2024. Combined with sustained interest rates, financing costs have eroded margins on all three projects. MGM and Genting have publicly stated they remain confident in long-term ROI, but Bally's reportedly explored a partner sale earlier this year.
Online Casino Competition
New York state online casinos remain illegal, but adjacent New Jersey and Pennsylvania iGaming markets capture an estimated $300M+ annually from New York residents crossing state lines or using addresses in legal states. If New York legalizes iGaming before all three resorts open — increasingly likely in 2027 — the brick-and-mortar revenue projections may need additional downward revision.
Tourism Recovery Lag
NYC tourism reached 90% of 2019 levels in 2025 but remains short of pre-pandemic peaks. Convention bookings (a key driver for integrated resort revenue) are lagging the broader tourism recovery, and downstate casino revenue projections assumed full convention recovery by 2027.
Regulatory Pressure Mounting
New York's Gaming Commission has held three public meetings this year on construction delays and timeline compliance. While none of the three licensees face immediate revocation risk, the commission has signaled it expects clearer construction milestones by year-end 2026 or it may impose performance penalties.
For an analogous regulatory environment, our coverage of legal casino markets includes detailed reviews like FanDuel Casino and DraftKings Casino, which operate under similar state regulatory regimes in legal iGaming states.
What This Means for Players
NYC-area gamblers expecting Vegas-style casino access in 2026 will need to wait longer. Realistic timeline:
- 2026 (this year): No new openings expected
- 2027: MGM Empire City phase one, possibly Genting phase one
- 2028: Genting full integrated resort, Bally's phase one
- 2029+: Bally's full resort, if completed
For now, NY residents seeking legal casino gambling continue to drive to Atlantic City, fly to Las Vegas, or use legal NJ online casinos when in-state. The best casino bonuses at major operators remain a key driver of the NJ iGaming spillover.
Impact on State Revenue
New York projected $1.5B in annual tax revenue from the three downstate casinos once mature. Delayed openings push that revenue out 2-4 years, with the state estimating a $400-600M revenue gap over the 2026-2028 budget cycle relative to original projections.
This revenue gap is one reason Albany is increasingly debating whether to expand legal sports betting tax rates or finally legalize online casino gambling — both of which could partially offset the slower brick-and-mortar ramp.
The Sweepstakes Casino Workaround
While New York legal real-money online casinos remain off the table, sweepstakes casinos have grown significantly in the state as a legal gray-area alternative. Our guide to sweepstakes casinos covers the operators currently serving New York players, including Chumba Casino, McLuck, and High 5 Casino.
Sweepstakes casinos generated an estimated $560 million in New York-attributed revenue in 2025, illustrating both the demand for legal casino-style entertainment in the state and the structural disadvantage facing the brick-and-mortar resorts. Until legal iGaming arrives, sweepstakes platforms will continue to absorb significant New York gambling demand.
FAQ
When will the new New York City casinos open?
Earliest opening is MGM Empire City in Yonkers, now targeted for Q2 2027. Genting and Bally's projects are tracking 1-2 years later than original timelines.
Why are the casinos delayed?
NYC construction costs have risen 22% since bids were submitted, financing costs remain elevated, and Bally's faces significant environmental review and community opposition challenges at the Bronx site.
Are online casinos legal in New York?
No. New York does not currently allow real-money online casino gambling. Mobile sports betting is legal in the state, but iGaming legislation has not passed.
How will online casino legalization affect the new resorts?
If New York legalizes iGaming in 2027 or 2028, it would likely reduce projected brick-and-mortar revenue by 15-25%, depending on cross-promotion access for the new resorts and their operating partners.
Final Thoughts
The downstate casino race is moving slower than anyone expected, and the once-rosy revenue projections are getting trimmed. For an alternative to the wait, our rankings of best online casinos in legal iGaming states offer the closest equivalent to what New York will eventually deliver — just available now in eight other states.
Join the Conversation
Be respectful. No spam. Strategy discussion welcome.